These also include plays not just musicals.
| Broadway Play | Broadway Theatre | |
| The 39 Steps | American Airlines Theatre | Comedy |
| August: Osage County | Music Box Theatre | Drama |
| Avenue Q | John Golden Theatre | Musical |
| Billy Elliot | Imperial Theatre | Musical |
| Boeing-Boeing | Longacre Theatre | Comedy |
| Cat on a Hot Tin Roof | Broadhurst Theatre | Drama |
| A Catered Affair | Walter Kerr Theatre | Musical |
| Chicago | Ambassador Theatre | Musical |
| Chorus Line, A | Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre | Musical |
| Come Back, Little Sheba | Biltmore Theatre | Drama |
| Country Girl, The | Bernard B. Jacobs Theatre | Drama |
| Cry-Baby | Marquis Theatre | Musical |
| Curtains | Al Hirschfeld | Musical |
| Equus | TBA | Drama |
| Godspell | TBA | Musical |
| Grease | Brooks Atkinson Theatre | Musical |
| Gypsy | St. James Theatre | Musical |
| Homecoming, The | Cort Theatre | Drama |
| Hairspray | Neil Simon Theatre | Musical |
| In the Heights | Richard Rodgers Theatre | Musical |
| Is He Dead? | Lyceum Theatre | Comedy |
| Jersey Boys | Virginia Theatre | Musical |
| Legally Blonde | Palace Theatre | Musical |
| Les Liaisons Dangereuses | American Airlines Theatre | Drama |
| Lion King, The | New Amsterdam Theatre | Musical |
| Little Mermaid, The | Lunt-Fontanne Theatre | Musical |
| Macbeth | Lyceum Theatre | Tragedy |
| Mamma Mia! | Winter Garden Theatre | Musical |
| Mary Poppins | New Amsterdam Theatre | Musical |
| Monty Python's Spamalot | Sam S. Shubert Theatre | Musical |
| November | Ethel Barrymore Theatre | Comedy |
| Passing Strange | Belasco Theatre | Musical |
| Phantom of the Opera | Majestic Theatre | Musical |
| Rent | Nederlander Theatre | Musical |
| Rock 'n' Roll | Bernard B. Jacobs Theatre | Drama |
| Seafarer, The | Booth Theatre | Drama |
| Shrek The Musical | Broadway Theatre | Musical |
| South Pacific | Vivian Beaumont Theater | Musical |
| Spring Awakening | Eugene O'Neil Theatre | Musical |
| Sunday in the Park With George | Studio 54 | Musical |
| Thurgood | Booth Theatre | Biography |
| Top Girls | Biltmore Theatre | Drama |
| Wicked | Gershwin Theatre | Musical |
| Xanadu | Gershwin Theatre | Musical |
| Young Frankenstein | Hilton Theatre | Musica |
